Louisiana Personal Injury Lawyer Blog
The following case deals with the important legal concept of prescription (similar to a statute of limitations) and the rules for adding new parties to a lawsuit after the deadline has passed.
Case Background
Randall Iles was injured in a car accident and sued his auto insurer, State Farm Mutual, under his uninsured motorist (UM) coverage. Nearly five years after the accident, he amended his lawsuit to include State Farm Fire, his umbrella policy provider. State Farm Fire argued that the claim against them was prescribed (too late) because they weren’t a solidary obligor with State Farm Mutual. The trial court agreed and dismissed the claims against State Farm Fire.
Understanding Prescription and Solidary Obligors
- Prescription: In Louisiana, lawsuits must be filed within a specific timeframe, or they become prescribed. For UM claims, that period is two years from the date of the accident.
- Solidary Obligors: When multiple parties are solidarily liable, they are each responsible for the entire debt. Suing one solidary obligor interrupts prescription for all of them.
The Court’s Analysis
The appeals court focused on two main issues:
-
Were State Farm Mutual and State Farm Fire solidary obligors?
- The court examined the insurance policies and found that they were distinct. The umbrella policy clearly stated that it was “excess” coverage, meaning it only applied after the primary auto policy limits were exhausted.
- Because the obligations were separate and not co-extensive, the court concluded that the two insurers were not solidary obligors.
-
Did the amendment naming State Farm Fire relate back to the original lawsuit?
- The court considered the “relation back” doctrine, which allows amendments to relate back to the original filing date under certain conditions.
- However, the court found that this doctrine didn’t apply because State Farm Fire was a completely new party, not a substitute for a previously misidentified party. Adding them was essentially adding a new claim, which was already prescribed.
Key Takeaways
- Timely Filing is Crucial: Prescription is a strict defense, and failing to file suit within the prescribed period can bar your claims, even if they are valid.
- Understanding Insurance Policies: It’s essential to understand the coverage provided by different insurance policies, especially when dealing with primary and excess coverage.
- Adding New Parties: Amending a lawsuit to add new parties can be tricky, especially if the prescriptive period has already expired. The “relation back” doctrine has specific requirements that must be met.
Outcome
The appeals court affirmed the trial court’s decision, confirming that the claim against State Farm Fire was prescribed. This case serves as a reminder of the importance of understanding prescriptive periods and the rules for adding new parties to a lawsuit.