Articles Posted in Negligence

by

Victim John Deshotels learned the hard way what happens when you donÕt have a an attorney represent you in an accident injury claim. He took his case to trial unrepresented and lost. Even after getting an attorney the damage was done and he lost again in a recent Court of Appeals decision. Plaintiff John Deshotels appealed the trial courtÕs granting of involuntary dismissal of his case against Nicholas J. Fontenot and his insurance company. Deshotels alleged he was rear ended by a car driven by Fontenot and injured. The case went to trial and following Deshotels’ presentation of his evidence, the insurance company moved for involuntary dismissal pursuant to La. Code Civ.P. art. 1672 (B).

Louisiana Code of Civil Procedure Article 1672 (B) states: that when there is no jury, a party When there is no jury, an action tried before the court may be over rather quickly. After a plaintiff has finished presenting their evidence, either party may then ask for a dismissal of the case based on the ground that the plaintiff has not shown any right to relief. The judge must rely on both law and the facts of the case that have been presented at that time. Then, the court is permitted to examine the facts currently presented and make a judgment against the plaintiff and in favor of the moving party. Or the court may decline to make any judgment on the matter until the close of all of the evidence.

Trial courts have discretion to grant an involuntary dismissal if, after weighing the evidence, they determine the plaintiff has not proved their claim by a preponderance of the evidence, or the more likely than not standard.

Continue reading

by

On May 7, 2010, the Donaldsonville community was saddened when 20 year-old Ryan Johnson was killed in a car accident when his car flipped after he collided with a semi-truck on LA 70. While this loss is tragic, it is also a reminder that accidents involving semi trucks should be treated differently that regular car accidents and usually require assistance from an attorney who has experience resolving these cases.

In a typical fender bender with another car, an attorney may not be required. After the collision, both drivers make sure they don’t have any injuries, call the paramedics if needed, exchange contact and insurance information, have the police make a report if necessary, and they settle the cost of damages through their insurance companies. Often in these situations, especially in small communities, the drivers know each other and can easily call the other if they need any additional information that they didn’t get immediately after the accident. It is a fairly straight-forward process.

Accidents between a car and a semi truck are different and require the driver of the car to be informed and consult an attorney soon after the accident. Truck drivers haul cargo across the country for a living. When they are involved in an accident, you are not just dealing with the other driver, but the company they work for. Trucking companies have similar liability insurance as the average driver; however, these companies are better equipped to handle accidents because they have already prepared for this situation. Trucking companies also have attorneys working to protect their assets that may only work on these types of cases. Trucking companies and their insurance providers are both business and have the goal of giving you the least amount of money for your settlement. It is important that you have someone fighting equally as hard on your side.

Continue reading

by

In a recent Louisiana Court of Appeals decision, Janika Johnson appealed a verdict in favor of Gilley Enterprises, owner of a Monroe McDonalds. Johnson, as a customer at the McDonald’s in 2006, was involved in an altercation with an employee. There was a history of ill feeling between Johnson and the employee because Johnson was dating the father of the employee’s child. Johnson called the other woman over to the counter, and a conversation ensued which turned loud and heated. The employee reached over the counter and struck Johnson in the face. Other store employees intervened. Johnson was told to leave and started towards the door. The other woman picked up a cup, dipped it into an open vat of hot grease, and threw the hot grease on Johnson, who suffered serious burns on her face and body.

Johnson filed suit against Littleton (the employee) and Gilley Enterprises, contending that Gilley was liable because their managers were negligent in hiring, training, and supervising Littleton and that Littleton’s attack occurred in the course and scope of her employment, making Gilley vicariously liable. Gilley responded that all of Johnson’s causes of action had prescribed. The trial court granted Gilley’s exception for the negligence claim but denied it pertaining to vicarious liability. Gilley filed a motion for summary judgment to dismiss the remaining vicarious liability claims arguing that Littleton was acting outside the course and scope of employment, the trial court agreed and Johnson appealed. On appeal Johnson argued that the trial court erred in concluding La.C.C. art 3493.10 was inapplicable to her claims of negligent hiring, training and supervision.

Louisiana C.C. art 3493.10 states:

Continue reading

by

In October 2007, a Norco tankerman was injured aboard the M/V DUSTIN CENAC at dock #2 of the Valero Corporation’s facility in Norco. The tankerman was completing the loading procedure of the barge when the Valero dock man prematurely began lifting the loading arm and he was pinned between the arm and a winch on the barge. He brought suit against his employer and owner of the barge, Cenac towing, and Cenac filed a motion for summary judgment. The motion was granted on February 12 when a Federal judge ruled that no issue of material fact existed as to whether they were negligent.

The Jones Act provides seaman with a cause of action for injuries that result from an employer’s negligence. To prove negligence, the injured party must prove that the employer had a duty to them which was breached and that the breach was the cause and proximate cause of the accident. Proving proximate cause goes beyond merely proving that without the breach of duty the injury would not have occurred but also that the injury naturally and foreseeably resulted from the breach.

In this case the judge found that nothing in the complaint or depositions showed negligence on the part of Cenac. While the injured tankerman’s attorney suggested possible negligence by the Valero employee and suggested the vessel may have been unseaworthy due to a malfunctioning loading arm, the tankerman testified that nothing done by the Cenac’s crew did anything to contribute to his injury.

Continue reading

by

Early in the morning hours of Saturday, February 6th, 20 year old Jamane M. County of Montgomery was driving a 2002 Honda Civic South on U.S. Highway 71 when he lost control of the car. According to an article on thetowntalk.com,

The car ran off the right side of the road, vaulted across a creek, hit an embankment on the opposite side and overturned.

County and two of his passengers sustained moderate injuries and were taken to nearby hospitals; County to Nathitoches Regional, 18 year old Kayla Monroe to Louisiana State University (LSU) Medical Center, and a male juvenile to Rapides Regional Medical Center. A third passenger,19 year old Kimber Vanantwerpen, was injured seriously and also taken to LSU Medical Center.

Continue reading

by

Admitting your elderly mother into a nursing home is supposed to relieve stress and lift a burden from your shoulders. You believe she is going to receive the proper care she needs that you are unable to provide.

Unfortunately, for Edward Lewis, tragedy happened after he made this tough decision. His 93-year old aunt, who Lewis considered a mother, drowned in a whirlpool at Easthaven Rehabilitation Care Center in 2002. The nursing home told Lewis that his aunt died peacefully in her sleep but it wasn’t until one month later he learned the truth — an employee had placed his wheelchair-bound aunt in a whirlpool unsupervised, even after Lewis told the staff he did not want her in the water. Sadly, actions that cause harm or even death to a nursing home resident can generate minimal response from the state.

In Louisiana, nursing homes are required to report all “suspicious deaths.” Per a NOLA.com article approximately 4,500 nursing home residents die every year in Louisiana and of 250 wrongful deaths reported from 1999-2005, only 15 of those deaths were labeled as “suspicious.” Steven Miles, a University of Minnesota professor who published a 2002 report called “Concealing Nursing Home Deaths,” said almost half of the reported cause of deaths in nursing homes across the nation is wrong. For example, back in 1998 in Arkansas one 78 year old nursing home resident

Continue reading

by

Wrongful death. Negligence. We hear these terms thrown out all the time when we read the newspaper or watch TV. Both terms have a similar connotation. We know something “bad” happened to someone, something that should never have happened. However, most people don’t really know what these terms mean.

The legal concept of negligence means that someone has suffered physical and/or mental injuries caused by someone else being careless. Negligence is not derivative of an accident – someone else was not diligent and that failure to act properly was the cause of the injury. An example is featured on <a href="http://realestate.nola.com/?classification=real+estate&temp_type=search&tp=RE_nola&tl=42&guid=114135"NOLA.com when a family suffered damage to their home because of an inspector’s negligence in failing to report defects in the house.

A wrongful death claim arises when the victim died as a result of someone’s negligence. This type of claim, the victim’s surviving family is eligible for the amount of damages. This differs from a typical negligence claim because there, the actual victim is alive and able to receive the damages. Originally, a wrongful death claim was nonexistent because presumably the claim for damages died with the victim. Today, luckily, that is not the case and the grieving family is eligible for compensation for their loss.

Continue reading

by

According to a recent article in New Orleans’ Times Picayune, Kenneth Allain of Tailsheek pled guilty last month to charges that he permanently injured a 75 year old woman by ramming his car into her while under the influence of prescription drugs. The accident occurred on Louisiana 41 about three miles south of Louisiana 21 in northeastern Tammany Parish. The injured woman, Edythe Proze, was driving in front of Allain and stopped to make a left turn when Allain continued driving, slamming into the back of her vehicle. Troopers at the scene determined that Allain was intoxicated and took a blood sample.

Allain pled guilty to first degree vehicular negligent injuring and was sentenced to ten years in prison: five years for the crash (the max allowed under state law), and five years because he was a repeat offender.

Proze was taken from the scene with moderate injuries. She is now faced with “life-changing” injuries and is living in an assisted-living facility.

Continue reading

by

Samuel Silverman Jr. was injured while working for BJ Services Company, a contractor for Bass Enterprises Production Company, hired to provide services on an oil well in Cado Parish. The injury was to Silverman’s knee and occurred because a hoist operator employed by another contractor at the site, Mike Rogers’ Drilling Company, dropped a cement head and pinned his knee against a derrick.

Silverman sued Rogers’ Drilling, alleging that the negligence of their employee (the hoist operator), caused the accident. Rogers’ Drilling tried to get around liability by filing a third-party demand against Bass under a provision in the contract between Rogers’ and Bass wherein Bass, as operator, agreed to indemnify Rogers, as contractor.

According to the provision, indemnification included a release of any liability and agreement to protect, defend, and indemnify against all claims, demands, and causes of any kind without regard to negligence of any party. Can such a strong indemnity clause be upheld under Louisiana law and the Louisiana Oilfield Anti-indemnity Act (LOAIA)? The trial court found the provision to be against the LOAIA and thus null and void, and in a decision this summer, the Louisiana Court of Appeals agreed.

Continue reading

by

According to a recent study published by the Road Information Program (a nonprofit group that evaluates highway data), Louisiana has the second highest auto fatality rate in the nation. In 2008, Louisiana had 2.02 deaths for every 100 million miles traveled. Montana was the one state with more deaths, at 2.12 per 100 million miles. As noted in a recent editorial in the Louisiana Times-Picayune, “That translates into 4,782 people who lost their lives on Louisiana’s roadways from 2005 to 2008.”

Researchers found that many factors lead to the higher percentage of deaths, including poor road conditions. In fact, according to the study, 44 percent of major state and local roads are in “poor or mediocre” condition. Additionally, 13 percent of Louisiana’s bridges are structurally deficient and 16 percent don’t meet current design standards. Poor roads are those considered to have deficient lane width and lighting and lack barriers and paved shoulders. The study found that these factors played a role in as many as a third of the fatal or serious accidents.

While road conditions in Louisiana are bad, the state is working towards improvements and recently used $1.2 billion in state surplus money and $500 million in federal stimulus money to renovate highways and bridges. The article notes “safety projects such as the post and cable barriers on Interstate 12 in St. Tammany Parish and on Interstate 10 in St. James are examples of smart, life saving measures.”

Continue reading
Contact Information
1140 St Charles Ave
New Orleans, LA 70130
Phone: (504) 521-6000
Fax: (504) 617-6300

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Please do not include any confidential or sensitive information in a contact form, text message, or voicemail. The contact form sends information by non-encrypted email, which is not secure. Submitting a contact form, sending a text message, making a phone call, or leaving a voicemail does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Copyright © 2016 – 2024, Berniard Law Firm
JUSTIA Law Firm Blog Design