Articles Posted in Miscellaneous

In May 2005 the Third Circuit of the Louisiana Court of Appeals upheld a significant general damages award rendered in favor of Clyde Rayburn of Hineston. Mr. Rayburn, an 83 year old widower, was injured in 2003 when he was stopped in his pickup truck at an intersection and was struck from the rear by a school bus. He sustained injuries to his right shoulder, neck, and lower back and the defendants stipulated to liability at a 2004 trial. While Mr. Rayburn’s neck and lower back complaints were resolved, at the time of trial he continued to have difficulty with his right shoulder.

According to the testimony of his physician Dr. Drury, Mr. Rayburn has a chronic complete tear to his rotator cuff. A chronic tear means that the tear initially occurred six months or more before examination (and the accident) and completely tore during the accident. Mr. Rayburn had no complaints of pain before the accident and was quite active. After the accident, however, he had difficulty lifting his arm over his head or reaching out to pick up anything, even something as light as a gallon of milk from his refrigerator. Dr. Drury also testified regarding the prognosis of the injury and indicated that Mr. Rayburn was not a candidate for surgery and, although he would have good months and bad months, his condition was permanent.

The trial court believed Mr. Rayburn’s testimony that the preexisting rotator cuff tear did not hinder his lifestyle which was affected for the worse by the accident. As such, the court awarded Mr. Rayburn $85,000 in general damages and $3,450.15 in medical expenses. The general damage award was appealed as excessive to the court of appeals.

With municipal governments around the nation facing massive budget shortfalls, many have already taken unprecedented steps in cutting traditional services. In Tracy, California, residents now must pay $300 phone charge for any 911 call they make or pay a $48 dollar yearly fee for the “unlimited” 911 plan. The change has drawn the ire not only of local citizens, but people across the country, perhaps fearful of what their own local governments may do to cut costs.

On the surface, residents of St. Tammany parish who rely on a dependable 911 system, may not see things quite as badly. According to a recent Times-Picayune article by Jeff Adelson, the local government recently spent $85,000 for installation of a 911 photo system designed to aid first responders arriving at the scene of an emergency. If national trends are any indication, however, local city and county governments throughout Louisiana will eventually face difficult decisions when trying to decide which services to improve and which services to scale back.

While not explicitly contributing to budget shortfalls, a recent delay in services helped cause one Covington homeowner untold frustration and possible property damage after the leftover problems from broken sewer elements went unattended for nearly six months. As Benjamin Alexandar-Blotch reports in his article from March 5 of this year: