Criminal Matter

August 22, 2010

St. Landry Parish Car Crash Expert’s Duties Help Police Understand How Accidents Happen

In 2010 the St. Landry Sheriff’s Department welcomed a traffic accident reconstruction expert among its team as Captain Brian Hundley successfully completed a course on accident investigation and reconstruction. Especially in fatal accidents or in cases where there are no eye-witnesses, car crash experts can play a pivotal role in determining the most probable explanation for how the accident occurred.

In an investigation, a crash reconstruction expert must rely heavily on evidence gathered by the police at the accident scene. Although the expert can consider a variety of physical evidence, including the road layout and traffic markings, tire skid marks, and the damaged vehicles themselves that remain after the occurrence of the crash, much of the expert’s analysis must be based on observations made after the event. For this reason, it is critical that police officers who respond to an accident scene are extremely diligent in preserving and recording evidence once the medical needs of the victims are addressed.

The reconstruction expert will review photographs of the roadway and vehicles and obtain detailed measurements of the site in order to create a diagram of the situation. This diagram is important for establishing the vehicles’ positions both before and after the impact.

August 18, 2010

Hit-and-run Incident Illustrates Civil and Criminal Trial Issues

by Berniard Law Firm

Fleeing the scene of an escalating argument, a driver injured two persons when he ran over them with his car. The incident happened in Minden on February 7, as reported by Jana Ryan. Local authorities believed the victims were merely bystanders and were not part of the argument. After brandishing a gun, the driver attempted to leave in his car, and he ran over the bystanders while trying to back away. The driver was later arrested on criminal charges of aggravated assault and aggravated battery stemming from the incident.

Events like this one often bring criminal charges against the person who injures another. However, the driver in this case may also be civilly liable to the injured victims; that is, in addition any criminal conviction, a court can hold him financially responsible for the injuries that resulted from his actions. To be held civilly, or financially, liable to a victim, generally a person’s actions must be the legal cause of the victim’s injury. The law does not even require that the person have intentionally injured a victim; a careless, or negligent, act may be sufficient to establish liability.

It is important to keep in mind, though, that criminal law and civil liability are administered very differently and that criminal convictions and civil remedies are distinct under Louisiana law. A conviction by a criminal court does not automatically ensure that a civil court will hold a convicted defendant financially liable for the injuries he caused. Nor will a person found innocent be guaranteed immunity from civil liability. Each type of court requires attorneys to establish different elements, and criminal courts require them to prove those elements with more certainty. This is true even if key words, such as “assault” and “battery,” seem to mean essentially the same thing in each court.

July 17, 2010

The Need to Hire an Attorney For Car Accidents Illustrated in Recent Case

by Berniard Law Firm

Victim John Deshotels learned the hard way what happens when you donÕt have a an attorney represent you in an accident injury claim. He took his case to trial unrepresented and lost. Even after getting an attorney the damage was done and he lost again in a recent Court of Appeals decision. Plaintiff John Deshotels appealed the trial courtÕs granting of involuntary dismissal of his case against Nicholas J. Fontenot and his insurance company. Deshotels alleged he was rear ended by a car driven by Fontenot and injured. The case went to trial and following Deshotels’ presentation of his evidence, the insurance company moved for involuntary dismissal pursuant to La. Code Civ.P. art. 1672 (B).

Louisiana Code of Civil Procedure Article 1672 (B) states: that when there is no jury, a party When there is no jury, an action tried before the court may be over rather quickly. After a plaintiff has finished presenting their evidence, either party may then ask for a dismissal of the case based on the ground that the plaintiff has not shown any right to relief. The judge must rely on both law and the facts of the case that have been presented at that time. Then, the court is permitted to examine the facts currently presented and make a judgment against the plaintiff and in favor of the moving party. Or the court may decline to make any judgment on the matter until the close of all of the evidence.

Trial courts have discretion to grant an involuntary dismissal if, after weighing the evidence, they determine the plaintiff has not proved their claim by a preponderance of the evidence, or the more likely than not standard.

March 17, 2010

Road Danger: Beware of Dangerous Drivers; Man Booked in Ouachita Parish for Third DWI

by Berniard Law Firm

Ouachita Parish deputies arrested Brandon Martin, of West Monroe, for driving while intoxicated, “DWI,” on Sunday, February 21. While this incident might seem relatively commonplace, a few aspects of Martin’s arrest make it noteworthy. According to a report by the staff at The News Star:

“When [the deputies] found [Martin], they said he was lying in the rear of the vehicle on top of musical equipment. Two people in the front seat said Martin had been driving.

Deputies said Martin declined a field sobriety test, but submitted to a chemical test that showed his blood alcohol content at .184. A blood alcohol level of .08 is considered intoxicated in Louisiana. The arrest report showed Martin was charged with DWI in 2005, 2007 and 2009.” (emphasis added)

March 15, 2010

Minden Man Arrested for Running Down Two People With his Car

by Berniard Law Firm

28 year old Arlandus Albertlee Green, Jr. of Minden has been arrested and charged with running down two people with his car.

Green, also known as Lance, has been accused of aggravated battery and aggravated assault. As reported in the Bossier Press Tribune and Minden Press Herald’s nwlanews.com,

Minden Police Chief T.C. Bloxom said on February 7, Green and Lamario Elkins began arguing on Sheppard Street. During the argument, Green pulled a Jimenez 9 mm and pointed it at Elkins.

March 2, 2010

Baton Rouge Hit and Run accident may lead to further court action

by Berniard Law Firm

As reported by the Advocate and WBRZ News Louisiana, police now have a suspect in the hit and run that killed 20 year old Mikel Carson on January 31st. According to an arrest warrant, Christian J. Cvitanovich of Melairie is wanted for striking down Carson with his 2005 Ford Expedition. At the time, Carson was walking down 1-10 to check on a woman involved in an unrelated vehicle crash.

According to the article,

Investigators with the Police Department’s Traffic Homicide Unit were told on Feb. 4 that the Expedition had been taken to a Metairie body shop… with the assistance of the Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office, the vehicle was impounded that afternoon and returned to Baton Rouge for further examination.