Louisiana Woman’s This latter part of the discussion regarding the McGlothlin v. Christus St. Patrick Hospital case is based upon the difference between issues of fact and law, and to who or whom such issues are to be determined. In this case, the issue gets blended with the difference between…
Articles Posted in Strict Liability
Louisiana Woman’s Knee Replacement Leads to ‘He Said, She Said’ Confrontation (Part I)
Most people’s fear of hospitals is usually justified in that one does not usually go to a hospital unless there is something wrong, or something negative has occurred. Everyone who seeks medical treatment, whether in a hospital or private doctor’s office, is seeking an expert’s diagnosis and treatment to prevent…
St. Landry Parish Accident Results in Reversal and DOTD Responsibility
Car accidents are never pleasant, but when an accident is worsened by construction debris left on the side of the road, the outcome can be disastrous. Once the pain and suffering has subsided, the question needs to be asked, who’s responsible? Do we look to the construction company, or do…
Statute of Limitations on Medical Malpractice Claims in Louisiana: Information Every Patient Should Know
One of the first things that must be determined in a potential medical malpractice claim is whether the statute of limitations bars the claim. An otherwise legitimate malpractice lawsuit may be invalid simply because the injured party waited too long to file the claim. In the State of Louisiana, the…
2nd Circuit Reverses in Part Caddo Parish Med Mal Case Over Causation Issue
With the vast criticisms that surround medical malpractice cases, it is no wonder why many keep a close eye on these types of cases. While it is very rare for an appellate court to do so, once in a blue moon an appellate decision will overturn a jury verdict of…
The Complexities of the Involuntary Dismissal of a Claim
A lawsuit can be resolved in many ways. Prior to formal court proceedings, the suit may be dropped voluntarily for one reason or another, or the parties might come to an agreement in mediation. If the case goes to trial, it may be resolved with the judge or jury entering…
Jones Act Lawsuit Fails Under Seaman Claim
“Plaintiff Lost at Seaman Claim” Robert Teaver may have fancied himself a man of the sea but the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit agreed with the District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana that there was no way he could establish his status as a…
Third Circuit Court of Appeals Shoots Down Lafayette Woman’s Claim Damages Were Too Low
Plaintiff Sherrie Lafleur was injured in an April 2007 rear-end collision on Ambassador Caffery Parkway in Lafayette. Mrs. Lafleur was waiting for a traffic signal when Brenda Nabours drove her vehicle into the rear of Mrs. Lafleur’s vehicle. The low-impact collision caused no damage to Mrs. Nabours’ vehicle and no…
3rd Circuit Ruling Regarding Workplace Injury – Part 3 of Series
Though Mr. Herbert’s primary argument was that he was outside the scope of his employment, he argued in the alternative that, even if the injury occurred within the scope of employment, the Defendants committed an intentional tort. Such a tort is the only recourse available to defeat a workers’ compensation…
Discussion Regarding Employment Injuries – Part 2
The issue of injuries within the scope of employment is not always black and white. Two concepts have somewhat complicated the matter: the borrowed employee and joint employment. Under the borrowed employee doctrine, a permanent employer may loan an employee to another, temporary employer. While under the temporary’s employ, the…