After filing a lawsuit, plaintiffs are required to notify defendants of the impending suit so that they may defend and respond to the claim. Without notice that a lawsuit has been filed against them, defendants’ due process rights may be violated if an unfavorable judgment is entered or rendered without…
Articles Posted in Miscellaneous
Appellate Court Denies Summary Judgment in Store’s Favor in Shoplifter Detention Case
According to the Louisiana Code of Criminal Procedure, a merchant may use reasonable force to detain a suspected shoplifter for questioning or arrest for up to an hour. La. Code Crim. P. Art. 215(A)(1). A merchant who acts under this provision is entitled to immunity from any civil actions arising…
Thirty Years of Asbestos Exposure Leads to Death
Over the past two decades, America’s working class has suffered the impact of exposure to asbestos. Before it was known that asbestos could lead to serious illness and death, people worked around the material without hesitation. Problems with exposure arise due to the fact that the fibers of asbestos, once…
Contractor Not Liable for Electrocution Death in St. Tammany Parish
The U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit upheld a District Court ruling in early 2011 allowing a contractor out of a negligence suit following a tragic incident in which a young man was electrocuted while trimming trees. The Court held Defendant Contractor Camp Dresser & McKee, Inc. (CDM) did not…
Lafayette City-Parish Consolidated Government Ordered to Pay Damages, Costs to Injured Bus Passenger
The plaintiff in this case, Eileen Laday, was a passenger on a bus owned by the Lafayette City-Parish Consolidated Government. The bus had been donated to the City-Parish in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. When the bus was donated, it was missing a plexiglass shield that was designed to keep…
Appellate Court Affirms Small General Damages Award in Minor St. Landry Parish Accident
In a prior post, we saw that the trial court is afforded considerable deference in the setting the amount of general damages in tort cases. More than 30 years ago, the Louisiana Supreme Court stated: “[T]he role of an appellate court in reviewing general damages is not to decide what…
Court Rules High School Football Stadium Bleachers Are Not Unreasonably Dangerous
On the evening of October 29, 2004, Jeanine Pryor, then 69, attended a football game between Barbe High School and New Iberia High School at Lloyd G. Porter Stadium in Iberia Parish. Pryor, who was there to see her grandson play, was recovering from hip surgery and required a cane…
Appellate Court Reverses Factually Unsupported Judgment in Car Wreck Case
In previous posts on this blog, we have discussed the elements that the victim of a car accident must prove in order to recover from an at-fault driver. Whether the defendant’s negligent conduct caused the accident and the victim’s injuries is a question to be resolved by the fact-finder. This…
Disabled Man’s Death Demonstrates Slipper Slope of Malpractice Claims
Gleason v. Louisiana Dept. of Health and Hospitals is a Medical Malpractice case arising out of the unfortunate death of a 47-year-old severely mentally challenged man, Donnie Gleason. Donnie had been a resident of Northwest since December of 1974 and was nonverbal and incapable of self-medicating, arranging or monitoring his…
The Impoverished Plaintiff and the Assessment of Court Costs
The Louisiana Code of Civil Procedure generally affords the trial court wide discretion in assessing the costs of litigation to one or more of the parties. “Except as otherwise provided by law, the court may render judgment for costs, or any part thereof, against any party, as it may consider…